Best Ever Homemade Classic Marinara Sauce

This Best Ever Homemade Classic Marinara Sauce is the real deal and the only Marinara Sauce you’ll want to use from now on!

Crushed tomatoes simmer all day with extra-virgin olive oil, oregano, crushed red pepper, plenty of garlic, and a generous helping of Italian red wine.

This sauce is rich, but delightfully simple.

Best Ever Homemade Classic Marinara Sauce recipe - This Best Ever Homemade Classic Marinara Sauce is the real deal and the only Marinara Sauce you'll want to use from now on! Crushed tomatoes simmer all day with extra-virgin olive oil, oregano, crushed red pepper, plenty of garlic, and a generous helping of Italian red wine for an incredibly rich, but delightfully simple, sauce.

Click HERE to save this recipe for Best Ever Homemade Classic Marinara Sauce to Pinterest!

We just had Kendall’s family birthday dinner the other night.

She requested Chicken Parmesan, so I made another huge pot of everyone’s favorite Best Ever Homemade Classic Marinara Sauce recipe.

I breaded some chicken cutlets, smothered them in a casserole dish with some of the sauce, topped them with a sprinkle of parmesan and a slice of fresh parmesan cheese.

Then, I baked the casserole dish until the cheese was melted and bubbly.

I have never tried to make my own homemade pasta, but I really love fresh pasta.

So, I bought some from the grocery store to serve along side the chicken parmesan.

We also had big Caesar salad courtesy of my mother-in-law (the kids are obsessed with her Caeser Salad), and artisan bread with Grandma’s garlic butter.

Everyone was STUFFED after the meal.

The birthday girl was pretty happy with her dinner.

Is this really the best ever marinara sauce?

You’ve probably seen lots of recipes around claiming to be “best ever.”

I promise you that this one really is the real deal.

Everyone asks me for the recipe and I can’t believe that I haven’t gotten it up on the blog before now.

The kids will beg for spaghetti night.

This recipe takes all day to cook, so I usually start it in the morning when I get back from taking the kids to school.

The kids will ask me when dinner is as soon as they walk in the door after school because they can hardly stand to wait.

Then, they will beg for samples of sauce, and sneak tastes by dipping crackers in the pot when I’m not looking.

I’m pretty sure if I ever left the pot unattended with all 4 kids in the house, I’d come home to half of what I thought that I was going to have because of all of their “samples.”

I even love spaghetti night, and it was something that I was previously totally tired of after my childhood weekly spaghetti nights (courtesy of store-bought jarred sauce).

But my Best Ever Homemade Classic Marinara Sauce is seriously next-level.

Best Ever Homemade Classic Marinara Sauce recipe - This Best Ever Homemade Classic Marinara Sauce is the real deal and the only Marinara Sauce you'll want to use from now on! Crushed tomatoes simmer all day with extra-virgin olive oil, oregano, crushed red pepper, plenty of garlic, and a generous helping of Italian red wine for an incredibly rich, but delightfully simple, sauce.

Click HERE to save this recipe for Best Ever Homemade Classic Marinara Sauce to Pinterest!

How to Make the Best Ever Homemade Classic Marinara Sauce

This recipe might look time consuming, and it is true – it does take a long time to cook.

But the great thing is that it is a relatively hands-off recipe.

Because this recipe does cook all day, I’ve written it to make a really large batch so you can prepare it less frequently.

The long cook time is worth it though.

Because if you can cook it 6 – 8 hours instead of just a couple of hours, the flavor of this marinara sauce gets deeper.

Start off by heating some extra-virgin olive oil in a large pot.

I like to use my Le Creuset Enameled Cast-Iron 7-1/4-Quart Round French Oven.

Between the 6 cans of crushed tomatoes, the red wine, and the olive oil, you’ll be putting about 184 ounces (nearly 6 quarts) of ingredients into your pot.

So, it needs to be relatively large so it can both accommodate the ingredients as well as allow room for stirring without overflowing.

After you heat the olive oil, you’ll add some garlic, crushed red pepper, and dried oregano.

Sauté this mixture until fragrant, then slowly add the cans of crushed tomatoes (stirring in between additions so it all mixes well).

Then add salt, sugar, and red wine.

If you are concerned about the alcohol in the red wine, there won’t be any left after 6 – 8 hours of cooking.

Instead, you’ll be left with lots of great flavor to enhance the tomatoes, garlic, and olive oil.

Bring the mixture to a simmer, reduce it to low, and cook all day long.

Your house will smell amazing.

Anytime I make sauce, everyone who walks in comments on how good the house smells.

We always end up having something using the sauce I’ve made that day for dinner (I have lots of recipe ideas below), and then I’ll freeze the rest in portions for later uses.

This is a great recipe to keep stashed in the freezer for a variety of uses and it provides a jumpstart on future dinner recipes.

Ways to Use Best Ever Homemade Classic Marinara Sauce

Looking some of our favorite ways to use this recipe for Best Ever Homemade Classic Marinara Sauce?

Check out some of these recipes that use Best Ever Homemade Classic Marinara Sauce, or browse the recipe index archives for even more great recipe ideas:

Best Ever Homemade Classic Marinara Sauce recipe - This Best Ever Homemade Classic Marinara Sauce is the real deal and the only Marinara Sauce you'll want to use from now on! Crushed tomatoes simmer all day with extra-virgin olive oil, oregano, crushed red pepper, plenty of garlic, and a generous helping of Italian red wine for an incredibly rich, but delightfully simple, sauce.

Click HERE to save this recipe for Best Ever Homemade Classic Marinara Sauce to Pinterest!

Take this Easy One Skillet Baked Ziti to the next level by using this best ever Homemade Classic Marinara Sauce.

Easy One Skillet Baked Ziti is the perfect, easy comforting pasta dish.

Use this best ever Homemade Classic Marinara Sauce for a dipping sauce when serving these Spinach, Ricotta and Tomato Calzones.

Ricotta is mixed with a combination of primavera style vegetables, parmesan, and fresh herbs to create a tasty primavera stuffing to fill manicotti pasta. The Manicotti Primavera is then baked smothered in homemade marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese for a comforting meal.

Sundried Tomato and Spinach Lasagna Rolls are stuffed with a decadent mixture of ricotta, sun-dried tomatoes, spinach, and Romano cheese, then topped with homemade classic marinara sauce.

Homemade DIY Pizza Night is one of our kids favorite nights! It also makes a really fun dinner party to have with another family over.

We love to do this with one of our neighbor families.

Make some Totally Awesome Pizza At Home and then use this recipe for Best Ever Homemade Classic Marinara Sauce for the sauce.

Brown some ground beef and simmer it in plenty of this Best Ever Homemade Classic Marinara Sauce for a super simple spaghetti night that the whole family will love.

If Baked Spaghetti is more your style, try this recipe for Baked Sausage and Vegetable Spaghetti.

For a simple Chicken Parmesan, make breaded chicken cutlets according to this recipe for Chicken Parmesan with Sun-dried Tomato Sauce.

Take a stash of this Best Ever Homemade Classic Marinara Sauce out of your freezer and use that to spoon over the breaded chicken cutlets.

Then, top with a sprinkle of parmesan and a slice of fresh mozzarella. Bake until the cheese is melted.

Saute a variety of veggies, your choice of meat (Italian sausage, cubed chicken, shrimp, etc.). Then, toss with pasta and a few heaping spoonfuls of this sauce for a super easy and simple meal.

Best Ever Homemade Classic Marinara Sauce recipe - This Best Ever Homemade Classic Marinara Sauce is the real deal and the only Marinara Sauce you'll want to use from now on! Crushed tomatoes simmer all day with extra-virgin olive oil, oregano, crushed red pepper, plenty of garlic, and a generous helping of Italian red wine for an incredibly rich, but delightfully simple, sauce.

Love this recipe for Best Ever Homemade Classic Marinara Sauce?
Sign up for Good Life Eats email updates and never miss another recipe!

Best Ever Homemade Classic Marinara Sauce

Prep Time: 5 minutes
Cook Time: 8 hours
Total Time: 8 hours 5 minutes
This Best Ever Homemade Classic Marinara Sauce is the real deal and the only Marinara Sauce you'll want to use from now on! Crushed tomatoes simmer all day with extra-virgin olive oil, oregano, crushed red pepper, plenty of garlic, and a generous helping of Italian red wine for an incredibly rich, but delightfully simple, sauce.

Ingredients

  • 1/2 cup Extra-Virgin Olive Oil
  • 4 1/2 tablespoons minced Fresh Garlic Cloves
  • 2 - 4 pinches Crushed Red Pepper Flakes
  • 2 1/4 teaspoon dried Oregano
  • 6 28-ounce cans Crushed Tomatoes (do not drain)
  • 2 teaspoons Sea Salt
  • 2 teaspoons Granulated Sugar
  • 1 1/2 cup Chianti or Sangiovese Wine

Instructions

  1. Heat olive oil over medium heat in a large cast iron pot 7 quart (or other heavy bottom pot) or larger in size.
  2. Add the garlic, crushed red pepper, and oregano. Sauté the garlic mixture for 2-3 minutes, until it becomes very fragrant.
  3. Slowly add the crushed tomatoes, 1 can at a time, stirring after each addition.
  4. After all of the crushed tomatoes have been added to the pot, add the salt, sugar, and wine.
  5. Stir the mixture well using a wire whisk.
  6. Bring the tomato mixture to a simmer.
  7. Then, reduce to low and cook all day (with no lid), stirring with a wooden spoon every hour so the bottom doesn't burn. 
  8. I like to start it in the morning so it can cook at least 6 hours but 8 is better. 
  9. Taste before serving and add additional salt, up to 1 more teaspoon at most usually, depending on how much it has cooked down. 
  10. You can do a larger amount if you have a big enough pot because it freezes really well. I use this for spaghetti, pizza sauce, chicken parmesan, etc. 

Notes

Freezing Instructions:


  1. Cool the sauce completely, then transfer to freezer safe containers or freezer ziptop bags - quart or gallon sized work well.
  2. If freezing in bags, make sure they are sealed completely, then double bag, and lay flat to freeze. Label containers with contents and date prepared.
  3. A quart sized bag will hold approximately 4 cups of sauce. A gallon sized bag will hold approximately 16 cups of sauce. I recommend freezing in portions that work for your family and the recipes that you'll typically use the sauce for.

Recommended Products

As an Amazon Associate and member of other affiliate programs, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Be sure to follow Good Life Eats on Instagram. Tag @goodlifeeats and include the hashtag #goodlifeeatsrecipes so I can see what you’re cooking up in YOUR kitchen!

Click HERE to save this recipe for Best Ever Homemade Classic Marinara Sauce to Pinterest!